Sam is forced to confront a childhood fear when a case takeshim and Dean to Kansas to investigate Plucky Pennywhistle'sMagical Menagerie, a local pizza chain that hosts children'sbirthday parties. Sam and Dean discover that the victims'children had recently been to the restaurant and drawn apicture of their worst fear, which then came to life to killtheir parent. While Dean confronts the man behind the magic,Sam is left to deal with some very angry clowns.